Special Offers

I was held hostage by Isis. They fear our unity more than our airstrikes | Nicolas Hnin

In Syria I found out that Islamic State longs to provoke retaliation. We must not fall under the trap

A s a happy Frenchman I am as distressed as anybody about the occasions in Paris. I am not surprised or incredulous. I understand Islamic State. I invested 10 months as an Isis captive , and I understand for sure that our discomfort, our sorrow, our hopes, our lives do not touch them. Theirs is a world apart.

Most individuals just understand them from their propaganda product, however I have actually seen behind that. In my time as their hostage, I satisfied maybe a lots of them, consisting of Mohammed Emwazi: Jihadi John was among my jailers. He nicknamed me Baldy.

Even now I in some cases chat with them on social networks, and can inform you that much of exactly what you think about them arises from their brand name of marketing and public relations. They provide themselves to the general public as superheroes, however far from the electronic camera are a bit pitiful in lots of methods: street kids intoxicated on ideology and power. In France we have a stating wicked and silly. I discovered them more dumb than evil. That is not to downplay the homicidal capacity of stupidity.

All of those beheaded in 2015 were my cellmates, and my jailers would play childish video games with us psychological abuse stating one day that we would be launched and after that 2 weeks later on observing blithely, Tomorrow we will eliminate among you. The very first few times our companied believe them however after that we concerned understand that for the a lot of part they were bullshitters having a good time with us.

They would play mock executions. Once they utilized chloroform with me. Another time it was a beheading scene. A lot of French-speaking jihadis were screaming, Were going to cut your avoid and put it on to your arse and upload it to YouTube. They had a sword from an antique store.

They were chuckling and I played the video game by shrieking, however they simply desired enjoyable. As quickly as they left I relied on another of the French captives and simply chuckled. It was so outrageous.

It struck me powerfully how technically linked they are; they follow the news fanatically, however whatever they see goes through their own filter. They are completely indoctrinated, holding on to all way of conspiracy theories, never ever acknowledging the contradictions.

Everything encourages them that they are on the best course and, particularly, that there is a type of apocalyptic procedure under method that will result in a conflict in between an army of Muslims from all over the world and others, the crusaders, the Romans. They see whatever as moving us down that roadway. Whatever is a true blessing from Allah.

With their news and social networks interest, they will be keeping in mind whatever that follows their homicidal attack on Paris, and my guess is that today the chant amongst them will be We are winning. They will be heartened by every indication of overreaction, of department, of worry, of bigotry, of xenophobia; they will be drawn to any examples of ugliness on social networks.

Central to their world view is the belief that neighborhoods can not cohabit with Muslims, and every day their antennae will be tuned to discovering supporting proof. The images from Germany of individuals inviting migrants will have been especially bothering to them. Cohesion, tolerance it is not exactly what they wish to see.

Why France? For lots of factors maybe, however I believe they determined my nation as a weak spot in Europe as a location where departments might be planted quickly. Thats why, when I am asked how we need to react, I state that we need to act properly.

And yet more bombs will be our reaction. I am no apologist for Isis. How could I be? Whatever I understand informs me this is an error. The barrage will be substantial, a sign of exemplary anger. Within 48 hours of the atrocity, fighter airplanes performed their most magnificent munitions rob yet in Syria, dropping more than 20 bombs on Raqqa , an Isis fortress. Vengeance was maybe inescapable, however whats required is consideration. My worry is that this response will make a bad scenario even worse.

While we are attempting to damage Isis, exactly what of the 500,000 civilians still living and caught in Raqqa? What of their security? What of the extremely genuine possibility that by cannot believe this through, we turn much of them into extremists? The top priority needs to be to safeguard these individuals, not to take more bombs to Syria . We require no-fly zones near Russians, the routine, the union. The Syrian individuals require security or they themselves will rely on groups such as Isis.

Canada withdrew from the air war after the election of Justin Trudeau. I frantically desire France to do the exact same, and rationality informs me it might take place. Pragmatism informs me it wont. The reality is we are caught: Isis has actually caught us. They pertained to Paris with Kalashnikovs, declaring that they wished to stop the battle, however understanding all too well that the attack would require us to keep battle or perhaps to heighten these disadvantageous attacks. That is exactly what is occurring.

Emwazi is gone now, eliminated in a union air campaign, his death commemorated in parliament. I do not grieve him. Throughout his murder spree, he too followed this double bluff technique. After killing the American reporter James Foley , he pointed his knife at the video camera and, relying on the next desired victim, stated: Obama, you should stop intervening in the Middle East or I will eliminate him. He understood extremely well exactly what the captives fate would be. He understood extremely well exactly what the American response would be more battle. Its what Isis desires, however should we be providing it to them?

The group is wicked, of that there is no doubt. After all that occurred to me, I still do not feel Isis is the top priority. To my mind, Bashar al-Assad is the concern. The Syrian president is accountable for the increase of Isis in Syria, therefore long as his routine remains in location, Isis can not be removed. Nor can we stop the attacks on our streets. When individuals state Isis initially, then Assad, I state do not think them. They simply wish to keep Assad in location.

At the minute there is no political plan and no strategy to engage the Arab Sunni neighborhood. Isis will collapse, however politics will make that occur. In the meantime there is much we can accomplish in the consequences of this atrocity, and the secret is strong hearts and strength, for that is exactly what they fear. I understand them: battle they anticipate. Exactly what they fear is unity.

Nicolas H nin is author of Jihad Academy, the Rise of Islamic State

Read more: http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/nov/16/isis-bombs-hostage-syria-islamic-state-paris-attacks